Freezing tolerance in relation to cooling rate in an adult insect

In the adult tenebrionid beetle Upis ceramboides unusually low cooling rates are required to demonstrate maximum freezing tolerance, and a very slight change in rate can reduce survival from 100 to 0%. Freezing to ?50 °C results in 100% mortality at rates above 0.35 °C/min, but no injury is apparent if the cooling rate is 0.28 °C/min. The lower lethal temperature, determined with a cooling rate of 0.17 °C/min, is about ?60 °C. The maximum cooling rate which allows full survival is nearly identical to optimal cooling rates previously found for mouse embryos and some lymphocytes, but the striking sensitivity to very slight changes in rate is unique to Upis. Most studies dealing with insect freezing tolerance have utilized rates of 1 °C/min or faster, and the failure of some of these laboratory studies to observe freezing survival may be due to the use of lethal cooling rates.