Recovery from acidification in boreal lakes inferred from macroinvertebrates and subfossil chironomids

Acidification of waters and soils caused by emissions and the long-range transport of air pollutants has been a serious worldwide problem during the last decades. The extent of the acidification problem in Finnish acid-sensitive forest lakes was examined in the Acidification Research Project (HAPRO) in the mid-1980s. The recent decline in the emissions of air pollutants has resulted in the chemical recovery of watersheds in many regions, and the present work on the recovery processes in acidified Finnish headwater lakes (REPRO) was launched to examine whether the chemical recovery has already been accompanied by biological recovery. The patterns of recovery were studied by re-sampling littoral macrozoobenthos in a subset of the previously sampled HAPRO lakes. Paleolimnological samples were taken in order to assess the possible dependence of lacustrine chironomid communities on the changing degree of acidification. Acid sensitive and moderately acid sensitive benthic species revealed slight recovery in the formerly most acidic (pH 5.5) but recently recovered lakes. The most significant factors affecting the response of benthic communities were increased mean lake pH and decreased labile aluminium concentration. Paleolimnological chironomid analysis revealed a slight response along the pH gradient, but also significant structural similarity between the present and pristine chironomid assemblages. This implies that no major changes in chironomid communities of these acidic lakes have occurred during the past centuries. The alternative future trends and threats to biological recovery in small headwater lakes are discussed.