Preemptive CD8 T-Cell Immunotherapy of Acute Cytomegalovirus Infection Prevents Lethal Disease,Limits the Burden of Latent Viral Genomes,and Reduces the Risk of Virus Recurrence

In the immunocompetent host, primary cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection is resolved by the immune response without causing overt disease. The viral genome, however, is not cleared but is maintained in a latent state that entails a risk of virus recurrence and consequent organ disease. By using murine CMV as a model, we have shown previously that multiple organs harbor latent CMV and that reactivation occurs with an incidence that is determined by the viral DNA load in the respective organ (M. J. Reddehase, M. Balthesen, M. Rapp, S. Jonjic, I. Pavic, and U. H. Koszinowski. J. Exp. Med. 179:185–193, 1994). This predicts that a therapeutic intervention capable of limiting the load of latent viral genome should also reduce the risk of virus recurrence. Here we demonstrate the benefits and the limits of a preemptive CD8 T-cell immunotherapy of CMV infection in the immunocompromised bone marrow transplantation recipient. Antiviral CD8 T cells prevented CMV disease and accelerated the resolution of productive infection. The therapy also resulted in a lower load of latent CMV DNA in organs and consequently reduced the incidence of recurrence. The data thus provide a further supporting argument for clinical trials of preemptive cytoimmunotherapy of human CMV disease with CD8 T cells. However, CD8 T cells failed to clear the viral DNA. The therapy-susceptible portion of the DNA load differed between organs and was highest in the lungs. The existence of an invariant, therapy-resistant load suggests a role for immune system evasion mechanisms in the establishment of CMV latency.Recurrence of productive infection by reactivation of latent viral genome in the immunocompromised host is a feature common to the members of the herpesvirus family (39; reviewed in reference 38). Specifically, in the case of human cytomegalovirus (CMV), the human herpesvirus type 5, primary as well as recurrent infection during the temporal immunodeficiency early after bone marrow (BM) transplantation (BMT) entails a risk of graft failure and severe organ manifestations of CMV disease (8, 44). Early findings by Quinnan et al. (24) have suggested a correlation between efficient reconstitution of the cellular immune response and the control of post-BMT CMV infection, and more recent clinical data have attributed this control to the reconstituted CD8 T cells (35). Accordingly, restoration of antiviral immunity in the critical phase before the reconstitution by BMT becomes effective should diminish the risk of CMV disease. Experimental research with the model of murine CMV infection has positively demonstrated the antiviral and protective efficacy of adoptively transferred acutely sensitized (31, 34) or memory (28) CD8 T cells recovered from immune donors as well as of short-term CD8 T-cell lines propagated in culture (32). These studies have been pivotal for clinical trials of a preemptive CD8 T-cell immunotherapy of post-BMT human CMV infection in patients (37, 43).Infection of the BMT recipient can accidentally result from the transmission of infectious virus, however, productive infection is more commonly initiated by reactivation of latent CMV in either the transplant or the recipient’s own organs or, occasionally, both (11). For the murine model system, we have previously demonstrated the existence of multiple organ sites of CMV latency at which the latent viral DNA is retained after the resolution of productive primary infection and after clearance of the viral genome from hematopoietic leukocytic cells in BM and blood (27). In accordance with the wide distribution of the latent viral DNA, recurrence was found to occur focally in any of the organs, which led us to propose the concept of multifocal CMV latency and recurrence (27). Most importantly, the incidence of recurrence was found to correlate with the load of latent viral DNA in the respective tissue. Specifically, low virus dissemination and rapid control of infection in immunocompetent adult mice resulted in a low load and was associated with a low risk of recurrence, whereas the delayed control of infection in neonatal mice resulted in a high load and was associated with a high risk. Furthermore, there were also organ-specific differences. In accordance with the high incidence of interstitial CMV pneumonia after BMT, the lungs were identified as having a high load of latent CMV (2, 17).It is apparent that antiviral CD8 T cells generated during primary infection as well as memory cells present during latency do not eradicate latently infected cells under physiological conditions, since latency would not exist if they did. However, it has been open to question whether adoptive transfer of antiviral CD8 effector cells could prevent the escape of virus into latency. We will show here that modulation of primary infection by experimental CD8 T-cell immunotherapy has indeed had an effect on the load of latent viral DNA in tissues. The effect of the therapy is of relevance, since the load of latent viral DNA can be kept below the threshold required for effective recurrence. Our data thus provide a further supporting argument for clinical trials of cytoimmunotherapy. Interestingly, however, the data also predict that no dosage of CD8 T cells will prevent the establishment of latency.