Autologous and Heterologous Neutralization Analyses of Primary Feline Immunodeficiency Virus Isolates

Feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) provides a model system with which the significance of neutralizing antibody (NA) in immunosuppressive lentivirus infections may be studied. To date, no detailed analysis of the neutralization properties of primary FIV isolates has been reported. In this study, we have conducted the first comprehensive study of the sensitivity to autologous and heterologous neutralization in a lymphoid cell-based assay of 15 primary FIV isolates and, for comparison, of one tissue culture-adapted strain. Primary isolates in general proved highly NA resistant, although there was considerable individual variation. Variation was also observed in the capacity of immune sera to neutralize heterologous FIV isolates. The ability of sera to neutralize isolates or for isolates to be neutralized by sera did not correlate with epidemiological and genetic relatedness or with the quasispecies complexity of the isolates. From the study of specific-pathogen-free cats experimentally infected with viral isolates associated with NA of different breadths, it appears that the development of FIV vaccines cannot rely on the existence of viral strains inherently capable of inducing especially broad NA responses.Feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) is a lentivirus that is regarded as the feline counterpart of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) because it produces persistent infections of domestic cats which, after an incubation period of several years, progress to clinical manifestations of immunodeficiency and neurological damage that closely resemble those observed in HIV-infected humans. FIV is therefore a valuable model for investigating many aspects of AIDS pathobiology and control, including vaccination (4, 11, 39, 56).Based on DNA phylogenesis, FIV isolates worldwide have been classified into at least five distinct genetic subtypes, designated A to E, with uneven geographical distributions (2). While there is little hope of developing a monovalent vaccine capable of protecting across different FIV subtypes, a more reasonable goal is the development of one or several protective immunogens for each subtype and subsequent selection of the immunogens on the basis of the subtypes prevalent in the area where the vaccine is to be used (56). However, because genetic diversity is also high within a subtype, especially in the env region (2, 42), successful vaccines will have to induce immune responses effective against a wide range of antigenically diverse strains. Mapping the immunological relatedness of FIV strains belonging to the same genetic subtype therefore represents a prerequisite for identifying shared critical protective epitopes and an essential step for ongoing vaccine development efforts. Similar problems exist for HIV vaccine development (33).Although the humoral and cell-mediated immune responses that will eventually prove important for vaccine-induced protection against lentiviruses are unresolved (3, 7, 17), the ability to evoke a broadly reactive neutralizing-antibody (NA) response would seem to be an advantageous feature of candidate immunogens because it would at least contrast the dissemination of the initial viral inoculum from the site of entry (8, 9). In previous studies, we found that cats immunized with a fixed-cell vaccine were protected against FIV challenge in the apparent absence of NA (27, 28), but it is possible that a detectable NA response could be elicited with improved vaccines, adjuvants, and immunization regimens.FIV vaccines must be designed to protect against strains of FIV as they circulate in nature. For this reason, it is important to learn more about the immunobiological properties of fresh clinical isolates, including their ability to evoke and interact with NA and their neutralizing determinant(s). Here we report on the sensitivity of 15 FIV isolates subjected to minimal passage in culture to neutralization by autologous and heterologous immune sera. Primary FIV isolates proved only slightly prone to inhibition by immune sera. However, certain isolates were more neutralizable by heterologous sera than others and certain infected cat sera neutralized fairly large numbers of primary isolates. A relationship was also sought between neutralization properties of the isolates and immune sera and a number of factors that theoretically might influence the induction or the activity of cross-reactive NA, including epidemiological and genetic relatedness and quasispecies complexity of the isolates. Finally, to ascertain whether the cross-neutralizing potency of anti-FIV antibody was dependent on properties of the viruses that had induced their formation, we studied the NA response of specific-pathogen-free (SPF) cats inoculated with selected FIV isolates.