Vibrio cholerae O139 Bengal: Combined Physical and Genetic Map and Comparative Analysis with the Genome of V. cholerae O1

A combined physical and genetic map of the genome of strain SG24 of Vibrio cholerae O139 Bengal, a novel non-O1 strain having epidemic potential, has been constructed by using the enzymes NotI, SfiI, and CeuI. The genome of SG24 is circular, and the genome size is about 3.57 Mb. The linkages between 47 NotI and 32 SfiI fragments of V. cholerae SG24 genomic DNA were determined by combining two approaches: (i) identification of fragments produced by enzyme I in fragments produced by enzyme II by the method of fragment excision, redigestion, and end labeling and (ii) use of the linking clone libraries generated from the genome of classical O1 strain 569B. The linkages between nine CeuI fragments were determined primarily by analyses of partial fragments of the CeuI-digested genome. More than 80 cloned homologous and heterologous genes, including several operons, have been positioned on the physical map. The map of the SG24 genome represents the second map of a V. cholerae genome, and a comparison of this map with that of classical O1 strain 569B revealed considerable diversity in DNA restriction sites and allowed identification of hypervariable regions. Several genetic markers, including virulence determinant genes, are in different positions in the SG24 and 569B genomes.Vibrio cholerae, a noninvasive, gram-negative bacterium, is the causative agent of the diarrheal disease cholera. The specificity of the somatic O antigen of V. cholerae resides in the polysaccharide moiety of the lipopolysaccharide present in the outer membrane, which forms the basis of the serological classification of this organism (42). The V. cholerae strains causing epidemic cholera have, until recently, been confined to serogroup O1, which consists of two biotypes, classical and El Tor. The classical biotype was responsible for cholera epidemics till 1961, when the El Tor biotype displaced it. V. cholerae strains other than O1, which are collectively called non-O1 vibrios, can cause only sporadic infections and are believed to lack the potential to cause epidemics (30). One of the two events, the more alarming one, has dominated the global cholera scenario in the present decade; this was the unprecedented emergence in late 1992 in India of a novel strain of V. cholerae which does not agglutinate with O1 polyvalent antiserum but has epidemic and endemic potential, a phenomenon that has never occurred in the recorded history of cholera (1, 13, 36). Strains isolated from different parts of India and Bangladesh during the epidemic were found to be of clonal origin (5, 6) and were classified as new serovar O139, synonym Bengal. The other event was the dramatic and unexpected reappearance of epidemic cholera caused by V. cholerae O1 El Tor in South America in January 1991, after a 100-year absence on that continent (21). These two events have necessitated a renewed look into all aspects of the organism that are related to pathogenesis. The epidemic caused by V. cholerae O139 persisted for about a year (31, 32) and was again displaced by El Tor. Several lines of evidence have, however, suggested that O139 originated from the El Tor biotype (4, 6, 10, 13, 43) by the acquisition of a 35-kb DNA segment which replaced most of the O1 antigen-encoding rfb gene cluster of the recipient strain (8, 14). Thus, serogroup O139 combines the virulent properties of epidemic strains with the outer appearance of nonepidemic strains.By using restriction enzymes which have a single site in either the core region or the direct repeat sequence (RS) of the CTX genetic element (27), it was shown that the genomes of most of the O139 strains have two copies of the CTX genetic element in tandem connected by two RSs (6). The chromosomal location of the CTX genetic element in an O139 strain is the same as that reported for El Tor vibrios. The organization of the virulence gene cassettes in different O139 strains showed genetic heterogeneity in the population. While most of the epidemic O139 strains have two copies of the CTX genetic element, in some strains the number of elements has been amplified and in at least one strain a copy of the element has been deleted (6).The genomes of El Tor strains isolated immediately before and after an O139 outbreak showed extensive restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) among themselves and with the genome of O139 (33, 46). In late 1996, the appearance of a V. cholerae O139 strain having altered antibiotic sensitivity compared to that of the O139 previously seen (29) has complicated the epidemiological scenario of V. cholerae and has necessitated an examination of possible rearrangements in the genome underlying such rapid changes in phenotypic traits, which are unexpected in well-characterized clonal strains within such a short period. In view of the fact that the genetic basis of V. cholerae tropism and pathogenesis is still mostly unknown, comparative genome mapping studies to appraise the extent of genome diversity will be of interest, particularly since the emergence of new variants of this organism having epidemic potential with altered genotypes or phenotypes is turning out to be widespread rather than exceptional (20). The physical map of a classical O1 strain has been constructed (12, 25), and there was previously no second map for comparison of the genomes of V. cholerae strains in more detail. It is in this context that the present report describes the construction of a macrorestriction map of the genome of O139 by use of the enzymes NotI, SfiI, and CeuI. About 80 homologous and heterologous genes and operons have been positioned on the physical map. A comparison of the V. cholerae O139 genome with that of classical O1 revealed several gross differences.