Phenotypic plasticity in the reef corals Montastraea annularis (Ellis & Solander) and Siderastrea siderea (Ellis & Solander)

Mature colonies of Montastraea annularis (Ellis & Solander) and Siderastrea siderea (Ellis & Solander) were transplanted reciprocally between four reef environments near Discovery Bay, Jamaica. Multivariate analyses of variables describing corallite structures show that colonies of M. annularis change their skeletal morphology after transplantation from that characteristic of their original habitat to that characteristic of the environment to which they were moved. Control colonies of M. annularis, however, retain the morphology characteristic of their original habitat after manipulation. Many colonies of S. siderea similarly altered their morphology after transplantation, but some retained the morphology characteristic of their original habitat. Most control colonies of S. siderea did not change after manipulation. In general, control colonies of S. siderea show more morphologic variation between skeleton deposited before and after manipulation within colonies and also between colonies within populations, than did control colonies of M. annularis.These results indicate that, although M. annularis shows more plasticity than S. siderea. both species have highly plastic phenotypes. A large number of characters describing the architecture of corallites respond to environmental factors such as light intensity, sedimentation rate, water activity, and food availability. The most plastic characters in M. annularis describe coenosteal features and the thickness of thecae. The most plastic characters in S. siderea describe the thicknesses of thecae. septa, and columellae.This study suggests that phenotypic plasticity is an important species attribute in scieractinians and may be a significant mechanism in controlling the distribution and abundance of scleractinians on reefs.