Qualitative study of decisions about infant feeding among women in east end of London

ObjectiveTo improve understanding of how first time mothers who belong to a socioeconomic group with particularly low rates of breast feeding decide whether or not to initiate breast feeding.DesignQualitative semistructured interviews early in pregnancy and 6-10 weeks after birth.SettingWomen’s homes in east end of London.Subjects21 white, low income women expecting their first baby were interviewed mostly at home, often with their partner or a relative. Two focus groups were conducted.ResultsWomen who had regularly seen a relative or friend successfully breast feed and described this experience positively were more confident about and committed to breast feeding. They were also more likely to succeed. Exposure to breast feeding, however, could be either a positive or a negative influence on the decision to breast feed, depending on the context. Women who had seen breast feeding only by a stranger often described this as a negative influence, particularly if other people were present. All women knew that breast feeding has health benefits. Ownership of this knowledge, however, varied according to the woman’s experience of seeing breast feeding.ConclusionsThe decision to initiate breast feeding is influenced more by embodied knowledge gained from seeing breast feeding than by theoretical knowledge about its benefits. Breast feeding involves performing a practical skill, often with others present. The knowledge, confidence, and commitment necessary to breast feed may be more effectively gained through antenatal apprenticeship to a breastfeeding mother than from advice given in consultations or from books.

Key messages

• Women who have seen successful breast feeding as part of their daily lives and perceive this as a positive experience are more likely to initiate breast feeding
• Embodied knowledge gained through seeing breast feeding may be more influential than theoretical knowledge about the health benefits for women of lower social class
• Listening to pregnant women talking about breast feeding could help clinicians assess the relative importance of theoretical and embodied knowledge for each woman
• Women hoping to breast feed but with little exposure to breast feeding may benefit from an antenatal apprenticeship with a breastfeeding mother
• Ideally apprenticeship would be with a breastfeeding mother from her social network to minimise the potential barriers of embarrassment and lack of confidence with strangers