Examination of unidentifiable spined loach individuals found in the overlap zone of two tetraploid species within a single river in Japan

An endangered tetraploid spined loach species, Cobitis takenoi (Cypriniformes: Cobitidae; hereafter called Tango loach) is known to inhabit only a single river in Kyoto Prefecture, Japan. Since Tango loach was discovered recently, in 2010, and only described in 2016, its morphology, ecology, and genetics are not well studied. Another tetraploid spined loach species Cobitis sp. BIWAE type A (hereafter, called Ohshima loach) inhabits the same river. The two loaches are reported as morphologically distinguishable from each other. Although the habitats of the two species in the river are segregated (Ohshima loach and Tango loach inhabit the upper and lower reaches, respectively), they overlap to a small degree in the boundary area. Recently, some individuals with morphological characteristics that are intermediate between the two species were found in the overlap zone. It was suspected that hybrids between the two species were produced since breeding seasons of the two species overlapped. To investigate whether the two species produce hybrids, we performed mitochondrial and nuclear DNA analyses on the unidentifiable individuals. Eight individuals unidentifiable to the species level collected in the river between 2017 and 2018 were examined and compared with the Tango and Ohshima loach species. Using mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) cytochrome b analysis, we found that six individuals had mtDNA types identical to Tango loach and two individuals had mtDNA types identical to Ohshima loach. Furthermore, sequencing analysis of nuclear recombination activating gene 1 (RAG-1) revealed that each species had species-specific alleles. The phylogenetic analysis indicated that alleles in Tango loach were divided into two clusters and those from Ohshima loach formed a single cluster. There were no discrepancies in the combination between mtDNA and nuclear DNA species types within each specimen. DNA fingerprinting analysis (AFLP) showed that the species-unidentifiable individuals exhibited distinctly segregated genetic groups corresponding with Tango and Ohshima loaches. In summary, no hybrids were detected from among any unidentifiable individual examined in this study. New conventional genetic method for discriminating the two sympatric loach species developed here can be effective tool for the conservation of the Tango loach since there was no strict diagnostic morphological character between them.