Characterization of the [4Fe-4S]+ cluster at the active site of aconitase by 57Fe, 33S, and 14N electron nuclear double resonance spectroscopy

57Fe, 33S, and 14N electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) studies have been performed to characterize the 4Fe-4S]+ cluster at the active site of aconitase. Q-band 57Fe ENDOLR of isotopically enriched enzyme, both substrate free and in the enzyme-substrate complex, reveals four inequivalent iron sites. In agreement with M?ssbauer studies Kent et al. (1985) J. Biol. Chem. 260, 6371-6881], one of the iron ions, Fea, which is easily removed by oxidation to yield the 3Fe-4S]+ cluster of inactive aconitase, shows a dramatic change in the presence of substrate. The remaining iron sites, Feb1,2,3, show minor changes when substrate is bound. Methods devised by us for analyzing and simulating ENDOR spectra of a randomly oriented paramagnet have been used to determine the principal values and orientation relative to the g tensor for the hyperfine tensors of three of the four inequivalent iron sites of the 4Fe-4S]+ cluster, Fea, Feb2, and Feb3, in the substrate-free enzyme and the enzyme-substrate complex. The full tensor for the fourth site, Feb1, could not be obtained because its signal is seen only over a limited range of the EPR envelope. 33S ENDOR data for the enzyme-substrate complex using enzyme reconstituted with 33S show that the four inorganic bridging sulfide ions of the 4Fe-4S]+ cube have isotropic hyperfine couplings of A(S) less than 12 MHz, and analysis indicates that they can be divided into two pairs, one with couplings of A(S1) approximately less than 1 MHz and the other with A(S2) approximately 6-12 MHz; the analysis further places these pairs within the cube relative to the iron sites. 33S data for substrate-free enzyme is qualitatively similar and can be completely simulated by two types of S2- ion, with A(S1) approximately 7.5 and A(S2) approximately 9 MHz; the full hyperfine tensors have been determined. The hyperfine values for the two enzyme forms correspond to surprisingly small unpaired spin density on S2-. 14N ENDOR at Q-band reveals a nitrogen signal that does not change upon substrate binding.