Homology of ciliary bands in Spiralian Trochophores

A number of hypotheses have been presented regarding the originsof the metazoans and, more specifically, the Bilateria. Usingvarious phylogenetic analyses, characteristics have been mappedon phylogenetic trees to infer ancestral body plans and lifehistory strategies of those ancestors. Many arguments on theevolution of the Bilateria are based on the presumed homologyof certain characteristics of extant larva and adults, includingvarious ciliated bands involved in feeding and locomotion. Thisarticle considers a recent study indicating that the second,downstream-collecting, ciliated band in the veliger larva ofthe gastropod mollusc, Crepidula fornicata, is actually derivedfrom secondary trochoblasts (derived from second quartet micromeres),that normally form part of the prototrochal band found in otherspiralian phyla (Hejnol et al. 2007). Despite previous arguments,these new findings suggest that the second ciliated band inthe veliger larva is not homologous to the metatroch found inthe trochophore larva of some other spiralians, such as theannelid, Polygordius lacteus. In the latter case, the metatrochwas reported to be formed by a different set of lineage precursors(derived from third quartet micromeres) (Woltereck 1904). Thesefindings have important implications for the interpretationof various hypotheses related to the evolution of metazoan phyla.