Comparison of the relative efficacy of an insect baiting method and selective media for diversity studies of Metarhizium species in the soil

Metarhizium are a commonly occurring group of entomopathogenic fungi normally found in soil. The most common methods to assess the diversity of Metarhizium species in soil are (i) the use of selective media and (ii) insect baiting using Galleria mellonella larvae. We compared the recovery efficiency from soil of four common species of Metarhizium (Metarhizium anisopliae, Metarhizium pingshaense, Metarhizium brunneum and Metarhizium robertsii) using these two methods. Firstly, we compared the number of colony forming units (CFU) produced in vitro when grown on two selective media, one containing chloramphenicol, thiabendazole and cycloheximidethe (CTC) and one based on the fungicide dodine (n-dodecylguanidine acetate) (DOD). Secondly, we artificially inoculated natural/non-sterile soil with the four fungal species at a rate of 2×10² and 2×10³ conidia g^?1of soil, baited with G. mellonella, and processed for evaluation using the selective media. The in vitro results showed that the greatest number of CFUs were recorded for M. brunneum. In contrast, when inoculated into soil, more G. mellonella larvae became infected by M. anisopliae. Finally, when using selective media, most CFUs recovered were for M. robertsii. The importance of our results in selecting a method to study the natural occurrence of Metarhizium in soil are discussed.