Negative effects of habitat degradation and fragmentation on the declining grassland plant Trifolium montanum

Changes in land use have resulted in a strong decline in the plant diversity of nutrient-poor grasslands, but little is known about the combined effects of habitat degradation and fragmentation on populations of individual species. We studied these effects on stage structure, recruitment, reproduction and offspring fitness in populations of the declining perennial grassland plant Trifolium montanum in central Germany. Density and survival probability of juvenile plants decreased with light competition, measured as leaf area index (LAI) above T. montanum plants, resulting in aged populations with few juvenile plants at unmanaged sites with higher LAI. Reproduction of T. montanum was not related to LAI, but increased strongly with local density, suggesting pollinator limitation in fragmented populations with a low density of flowering plants. In the common garden, the survival of sown offspring increased with mean seed size, whereas seed production of offspring decreased with isolation, and in strong contrast to previous studies, also decreased with size and density of the population of origin. This could be due to increased inbreeding because of pollination between closely related neighbouring plants in dense and large populations. Our results indicate that both habitat degradation and fragmentation have negative effects on populations of T. montanum, but affect different phases of the life cycle. In the short term, the effects of habitat degradation are more important than those of fragmentation, and populations of T. montanum are primarily threatened by an increase in light competition in unmanaged sites, which rapidly affects the dynamics of the populations. The observed opposite effects of habitat fragmentation on reproduction and offspring fitness indicate that the effects of population size, density and isolation on plant fitness and population viability may be complex.