Evolution Within a Bizarre Phylum: Homologies of the First Echinoderms

SYNOPSIS. The Extraxial/Axial Theory (EAT) of echinoderm skeletalhomologies describes two major body wall types: axial and extraxial.The latter is subdivided into perforate and imperforate regions.Each of the regions has a distinctly different source in earlylarval development. Axial skeleton originates in the rudiment,and develops in association with the pentaradially arrangedhydrocoel according to specific ontogenetic principles. Perforateand imperforate extraxial regions are associated with the leftand right somatocoels respectively, are not governed by ontogeneticprinciples of plate addition, and are products of the non-rudimentpart of the larval body. The morphology of even the most bizarreof the earliest echinoderms can be explored using the EAT. Amongthese, edrioasteroid-like taxa best fit the idea that formsexpressing archimery in the sequential arrangement of axial,perforate extraxial, and imperforate extraxial regions are thefirst echinoderms. Metamorphosis is especially marked in cladesthat have a high axial to extraxial skeleton ratio because structuresdeveloping from the non-rudiment part are suppressed in favorof the developing axial elements during this process. However,inearly echinoderms, extraxial skeleton makes up a far largerproportion of the body wall than axial, implying that metamorphosiswas not as significant a part of the developmental trajectoryas it is in more recently evolved taxa. Echinoderm radiationconsists of a succession of apomorphies that reduced the expressionof extraxial components but increased the influence of axialones, with a concomitant increase in the prominence of metamorphosis.