Formation of cluster roots and mycorrhizal status of Comptonia peregrina and Myrica pensylvanica in Maine, USA

Extent of cluster (proteoid) root formation in the field was examined in relation to availability of P and successional status of the site in two actinorhizal, N₂-fixing shrubs. Comptonia peregrina (L.) Coult. and Myrica pensylvanica Loisel. In C. peregrina cluster roots were present at all 13 sites and comprised between 0.2 and 19% of total fine root dry weight. Cluster root formation was most extensive at recently disturbed sites and was negatively correlated with cover of associated woody species (r =−0.85), litter depth (r =−0.81) and available (extractable) soil P (r =−0.75). In M. pensylvanica cluster roots were present at all 11 sites and comprised between 6 and 20% of total fine root dry weight. On mineral soils (n = 6), extent of cluster root formation was negatively correlated (r =−0.86) with cover of associated woody species and with litter depth (r =−0.78; P = 0.07). Comptonia peregrina and M. pensylvanica lack functional mycorrhizae at these sites because only intracellular infections were found and these lacked arbuscules. None of 22 non-N₂-fixing, dominant woody species associated with C. peregrina and M. pensylvanica formed cluster roots. Cluster roots probably allow C. peregrina and M. pensylvanica to obtain sufficient P from nutrient-poor soils in the absence of functional mycorrhizae. Extensive cluster root formation on disturbed, early successional sites may aid these species in colonizing these sites because they have to form only one symbiosis (with Frankia ) and not two (with Frankia and a mycorrhizal fungus).