The effects of land use upon water chemistry,particularly nutrient enrichment,in shallow lowland lakes: comparative studies of three lochs in Scotland

Three shallow, lowland lochs (lakes) in the Tayside region of Scotland, experiencing the same climatic regime, were found to be dimictic lakes showing similar clinograde oxygen distributions in summer. Land use differences in their catchments were shown to result in estimated total nutrient surface loadings from 0.3 to 32 g m^–2 a^–1 phosphorus and from 4 to 240 g m^–2 a^–1 nitrogen. The major ions in the lochs were calcium and carbonate, but with elevated sulphate levels in all three lochs and an increase in sodium, chloride and sulphate in Forfar loch, which was affected by sewage effluent. Conductivity and total alkalinity showed marked increases with greater intensity of land use, from 64 to 439 µS cm^–1 and 0.5–3 meq l^–1 Maximum winter loch concentrations of soluble reactive phosphorus ranged from 60 to just under 5 000 mg m^–3 and of inorganic nitrogen from 500 to 10500 mg m^–3. Maximum chlorophyll a ranged from 20 to 250 mg m^–3 and comparisons indicated that above winter levels of 5000 mg m^–3 N and 500 mg m^–3 P, the nutrient-chlorophyll relationships did not hold. Predictions of nutrient input, from land use categories and soil losses of N and P derived from other north temperate areas, were shown to be comparable with inputs calculated from loch measurements. Models predicting loch concentrations of phosphorus from inputs were comparable with measured concentrations, but predictions of chlorophyll and transparency became less accurate with higher nutrient levels. The lochs were mesotrophic (the Lowes), eutrophic (Balgavies) and hypertrophic (Forfar) under the several classification systems used. The implications of their nutrient status for lake management are discussed and the value of studying this unique lake series in a similar physical environment but with considerable chemical differences is considered.