A comparison of methods of seed tuber inoculation for assessing the susceptibility of potato cultivars to blackleg (Erwinia carotovora subsp. atroseptica) in the field

Experiments were done with the aim of developing a reliable method for assessing the susceptibility of potato cultivars to blackleg caused by Erwinia carotovora subsp. atroseptica, in the field. Over four years seed tubers were either stab-inoculated at the heel-end prior to planting, vacuum infiltrated with bacteria just after harvest or vacuum infiltrated prior to sprouting and after ‘cutting’ or ‘pricking’. Stab inoculation produced fewer diseased plants but generally a greater range of symptoms than vacuum infiltration. Vacuum infiltrated ‘cut’ seed gave most disease whereas infiltration at harvest and infiltration of ‘pricked’ seed gave similar disease incidence. The cultivar Maris Piper was more resistant than Desiree in 1981 and 1982, and Pentland Javelin than Ulster Sceptre in 1983 and 1984, largely irrespective of the inoculation treatment. Irrigation improved yields but did not affect disease symptoms. In further field experiments over three years, each with a minimum of 20 cultivars, seed tubers were sliced just before planting at a standard distance from the apex and inoculated by applying a pad impregnated with inoculum. Differences were shown between cultivars and it is suggested that the method could be adapted for testing for blackleg susceptibility under controlled environment conditions.