Variability in early post-settlement mortality in intertidal mussels and the role of size at settlement

Early post-settlement mortality is difficult to measure in mobile benthic taxa such as mussels. Field studies typically employ settlement collectors that often contain empty shells of dead individuals, which are usually disregarded. Here, empty shells of pediveligers, i.e. recent settlers that died before beginning to grow as juveniles, were used to assess temporal and spatial patterns of early mortality in mussels, whether size at settlement determined mortality, and whether mortality was density-dependent. This study took place at two intertidal sites in a large harbour in central New Zealand where monthly cohorts of mussels were collected over a 2-year period. Monthly mortality varied substantially, ranging from 0% to 42.6%, but not across the two sites that were 27?km apart. Although there was no density-dependent mortality evident within cohorts, the proportion of pediveligers which were dead on collection was highly positively correlated across sites. Live settlers were on average larger than dead settlers, and the size distribution of dead settlers was shifted toward smaller sizes compared to live settlers. At the extremes, of all settlers with shell length of 260?µm or less, 72% were dead on collection. By contrast, for settlers 310?µm or greater in length, 6% were dead. Together, these results (1) suggest that in this system size at settlement may be an important determinant of very early, peri-metamorphic mortality in mussels, with smaller settlers at higher risk, and (2) demonstrate the value in evaluating dead pediveligers for assessing natural early post-settlement mortality in mussels.