TaqMan real-time PCR versus four conventional PCR assays for detection of apple proliferation phytoplasma

A recently developed TaqMan real-time PCR assay for detection of apple proliferation phytoplasma was evaluated in comparison to four conventional PCR-based methods with the aim to assess its potential for research and routine applications. All five protocols were tested in parallel on the same DNA isolates obtained from orchard trees. The performance of the methods was evaluated by means of sensitivity, specificity, susceptibility to inhibition, handling effort, testing time, assay expenses, and potential risk for operator and environment. Compared to the conventional PCR methods, the TaqMan real-time PCR procedure combined the highest test sensitivity with the highest test specificity and was, above all, not susceptible to PCR inhibition. Furthermore, TaqMan real-time PCR had the simplest and fastest testing process, involving a minimum of handling steps. Its disadvantage is the high cost of consumables and reagents, exceeding that of a standard PCR procedure up to four-fold. However, the higher material costs could be compensated by considerably lower personnel costs and by saving expenses for hazardous waste disposal. Due to the simple testing procedure and the output of results as numeric data the TaqMan real-time PCR assay has a high potential for automation, and seems to represent the currently most suitable method for large-scale testing procedures.