Male ornamentation and its condition-dependence in a paternal mouthbrooding cardinalfish with extraordinary sex roles

Cardinalfishes, in which males alone provide mouthbrooding, are likely candidates for sex-role reversal because of a higher potential reproductive rate for females than for males. In the gregarious cardinalfish, Apogon notatus, females establish breeding territories to form pairs prior to the breeding season. Within breeding pairs, females are more active in courtship and in attacks against conspecific intruders. Sex roles thus seem to be behaviorally reversed. The operational sex ratio is, however, male-biased because females suffer higher mortality than males and consequently males predominate in number in the adult population, leading to the prediction that males would be sexually selected. In the present study, morphological measurements showed that males had a protrudent lower lip that was expressed markedly during the breeding season. Field observation revealed that males with a longer and wider lip were preferentially accepted as a mating partner by territorial females. The male lip size positively correlated with their somatic condition, suggesting that the ornamental lip has evolved through indicator mechanisms of sexual selection. By contrast, females had longer fins than males, but these sexual dimorphisms were less pronounced and most of them were seasonally constant. These results support the prediction that sexual selection acts on males in this fish. Electronic Publication