WOOD ANATOMY OF BUBBIA (WINTERACEAE), WITH COMMENTS ON ORIGIN OF VESSELS IN DICOTYLEDONS

Quantitative and qualitative features of wood anatomy are reported for ten collections of seven species of Bubbia. Variations on the basic plan for Winteraceae can be interpreted in terms of taxonomic and ecological distinctions. Tracheid length is correlated with plant size and habit: tracheids are shortest in shrubs. Tracheid wall thickness and ray cell wall thickness distinguish species. Ray cell procumbency and multiseriate ray width increase with age. Growth rings occur only in a species from stream margins. SEM studies reveal absence of a warty layer within tracheids. Helical thickenings are absent. Presence of these two features in Pseudowintera may be correlated with the cool temperate habitats of that genus. Overlap areas of tracheids in Bubbia show various degrees of scalariform pitting, ranging from none (B. semecarpoides) to abundant presence (B. balansae). Perforation-like pits in tracheids of the latter prove, with SEM studies, to have pit membranes containing porosities less than 1 μm in diameter. Scalariform pitting on overlap areas is absent in earlier secondary xylem and increases during later secondary xylem. Scalariform lateral wall pitting can occur in abnormally wide tracheids formed after pauses in cambial activity. These facts show that primitive dicotyledon woods like those of Bubbia can activate genetic information for scalariform end wall patterns and lateral wall pitting such as primitive vessels show without the intervention of paedomorphosis. Paedomorphosis in dicotyledon woods is held still to apply only to special herbaceous and herblike growth forms, not to primarily woody plants. Progenesis (in xylem, loss of secondary xylem) is not held to be necessary to account for the scalariform patterns seen in tracheary elements of primitive dicotyledons. Reasons are given for rejection of the hypothesis that Winteraceae and other woody dicotyledons (Amborella, Sarcandra, Tetracentron, Trochodendron) are secondarily vesselless.