Homology Requirements for Unequal Crossing over in Humans

To gain insight into mechanisms of unequal homologous recombination in vivo, genes generated by homologous unequal crossovers in the human beta-globin gene cluster were examined by nucleotide sequencing and hybridization experiments. The naturally occurring genes studied included one delta-beta Lepore-Baltimore fusion gene, one delta-beta Lepore-Hollandia fusion gene, 12 delta-beta Lepore-Boston genes, one A gamma-beta fusion Kenya gene, one A gamma-G gamma fusion (the central gene of a triplication) and one G gamma-A gamma fusion. A comparison of the nucleotide sequences of three Lepore-Boston genes indicates that they were derived from at least two independent homologous but unequal crossover events, although the crossovers occurred within the same 58-bp region. Nine additional Lepore-Boston genes from individuals of various ethnic origins were shown, by hybridization to specific oligonucleotide probes, to have been generated by a crossover in the same region as the sequenced genes. Evidence for gene conversion accompanying a homologous unequal crossover event was found in only one case (although some of the single nucleotide differences observed in other genes in this study may be related to the crossover events in ways that we do not presently understand). Thus, as judged by this limited sample, concurrent gene conversions are not commonly associated with homologous but unequal exchange in humans in vivo. Classification of the recombinant chromosomes by their polymorphic restriction sites in the beta-globin gene cluster indicated that the Lepore-Boston genes are found in at least six different haplotype backgrounds. Therefore the total number of independent examples in this study is at least 6, and at most 12. We have shown that in at least six cases of genes that have arisen by homologous but unequal crossing over in vivo, each event occurred in a relatively extensive region of uninterrupted identity between the parental genes. This preference cannot be explained by a mechanism whereby crossovers occur at random within misaligned related but not identical genes. In general, crossovers occur in regions that are among the largest available stretches of identity for a particular pair of mismatched genes. Our data are in agreement with those of other types of studies of homologous recombination, and support the idea that sequence identity, rather than general homology, is a critical factor in homologous recombination.