Malatesta转基因研究:引证分析及相关证据

发表多篇以转基因农产品饲喂动物而导致健康损害论文的维罗纳大学(University of Verona)学者Manuela Malatesta,是国际上采用实验方法研究转基因生物安全领域有影响力的学者之一。通过对美国Web of Science数据平台全部论文的检索,重点分析了其所发表的10篇转基因毒理学论文的研究内容、研究方法与结论,并追踪其研究的相关证据及学术界对其研究的评价,在此基础上,分析该研究方法与结论的可靠性。研究发现,Malatesta所发表转基因存在安全隐患的10篇研究论文,由于其研究材料及方法上所存在的问题除了个别存在明显错误的论文无法重现而被学术界所否定外,其余论文均被后续采用规范研究方法的同类研究所推翻。

Malatesta's Transgenic Research: Citation Analysis and Relevant Evidence

Manuela Malatesta, University of Verona scholar, published a number of papers that feeding animals with genetically modified agricultural products caused health damage. She is one of the international influential scholars in researching the safety of Genetically Modified Organisms using experimental methods. Based on Malatesta's literature from Web of Science data, the research contents, methods and conclusions of 10 papers which hold toxicology view of Genetically Modified agricultural products were investigated. According to its related tracking evidence and academia evaluation, its reliability of research methods and conclusions were discussesd. The results showed that Malatesta's literature, which hold unsafe view of Genetically Modified agricultural products, were denied by the academia and follow-up similar studies using normative research methods since Malatesta's research materials and methods had problems.