Evolutionary Significance of the Entepicondylar Foramen of the Humerus in New World Monkeys (Platyrrhini)

Although consistently absent in extant catarrhine monkeys, the presence and absence of the entepicondylar foramen of the humerus (EEF) vary greatly among living and fossil platyrrhines. Aiming to test the mode of evolution of this character in platyrrhine phylogeny, we performed stochastic character mapping of the presence and absence of the EEF based on museum material and literature research. We also tested for phylogenetic signal of the EEF and its correlation with semi-brachation, vertical clinging, and manipulative foraging in New World monkeys. We found more losses than gains of the EEF in the Haplorhini and Platyrrhini phylogenies. The EEF showed a strong phylogenetic signal congruent with a Brownian model of evolution. All models that assumed a dependence between foraging and locomotion behaviors showed a better fit to the data, but the differences from an independent model were not statistically significant. Thus, we assume that the observed pattern could have originated from genetic drift, except in Leontopithecus where the EEF appears to have been lost due to the narrowing of the distal humerus. Although not functionally relevant, the presence and absence of EEF is taxonomically useful for discriminating between the Aotus and Callicebus species groups, and diagnoses large platyrrhine clades such as marmosets and Atelidae. Thus, it should be considered when inferring systematic relationships among living and extinct platyrrhines.