Lack of Mate-guarding in a Territorial Passerine Bird with a Low Intensity of Sperm Competition,the Pied Flycatcher; (Ficedula hypoleuca)

We examined a Norwegian population of pied flycatchers (Ficedula hypoleuca) for behaviour associated with the paternity-protection tactic of mate-guarding and found that this tactic was absent. The absence of mate-guarding and the fact that pied flycatchers do not have a high rate of copulation make this population unusual to the extent that the current literature implies that, in birds, one or other paternity guard should be present. Comparison of our population with a Swedish population that does exhibit mate-guarding lends some support to the notion that differences in nesting density may drive the relative risk of extra-pair copulation, leading to the need for paternity guards such as mate-guarding. However, we conclude that, whilst the results of both our study and the Swedish study are consistent with the nesting-density hypothesis, there is at least one other plausible hypothesis that fits the available data. Specifically, we direct attention to the role of the female in determining overall patterns of pair behaviour and, potentially, the rate of extra-pair paternity, challenging the primacy of male—male competition as the driving force behind the sperm-competition dynamics of this species.