Avoiding the Personhood Issue: Abortion,Identity, and Marquis's ‘Future‐Like‐Ours’ Argument |
| |
Authors: | Eric Reitan |
| |
Abstract: | One reason for the persistent appeal of Don Marquis' ‘future like ours’ argument (FLO) is that it seems to offer a way to approach the debate about the morality of abortion while sidestepping the difficult task of establishing whether the fetus is a person. This essay argues that in order to satisfactorily address both of the chief objections to FLO – the ‘identity objection’ and the ‘contraception objection’ – Marquis must take a controversial stand on what is most essential to being the kind of entity that an adult human being is. Such a stand amounts to a controversial account of personhood. To the extent that FLO's success depends on accepting such a controversial metaphysical view, one apparent attraction of FLO proves illusory. |
| |
Keywords: | abortion personhood personal identity contraception Future Like Ours ethics |
|
|