The effect of patients' sex on physicians' recommendations for total knee arthroplasty

Background

The underuse of total joint arthroplasty in appropriate candidates is more than 3 times greater among women than among men. When surveyed, physicians report that the patient''s sex has no effect on their decision-making; however, what occurs in clinical practice may be different. The purpose of our study was to determine whether patients'' sex affects physicians'' decisions to refer a patient for, or to perform, total knee arthroplasty.

Methods

Seventy-one physicians (38 family physicians and 33 orthopedic surgeons) in Ontario performed blinded assessments of 2 standardized patients (1 man and 1 woman) with moderate knee osteoarthritis who differed only by sex. The standardized patients recorded the physicians'' final recommendations about total knee arthroplasty. Four surgeons did not consent to the inclusion of their data. After detecting an overall main effect, we tested for an interaction with physician type (family physician v. orthopedic surgeon). We used a binary logistic regression analysis with a generalized estimating equation approach to assess the effect of patients'' sex on physicians'' recommendations for total knee arthroplasty.

Results

In total, 42% of physicians recommended total knee arthroplasty to the male but not the female standardized patient, and 8% of physicians recommended total knee arthroplasty to the female but not the male standardized patient (odds ratio [OR] 4.2, 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.4–7.3, p < 0.001; risk ratio [RR] 2.1, 95% CI 1.5–2.8, p < 0.001). The odds of an orthopedic surgeon recommending total knee arthroplasty to a male patient was 22 times (95% CI 6.4–76.0, p < 0.001) that for a female patient. The odds of a family physician recommending total knee arthroplasty to a male patient was 2 times (95% CI 1.04–4.71, p = 0.04) that for a female patient.

Interpretation

Physicians were more likely to recommend total knee arthroplasty to a male patient than to a female patient, suggesting that gender bias may contribute to the sex-based disparity in the rates of use of total knee arthroplasty.Disparity in the use of medical or surgical interventions based on patient characteristics, such as sex, ethnic background or socioeconomic status, is an important health care issue.¹ Women are less likely than men to receive lipid-lowering medication after a myocardial infarction,² receive kidney dialysis,³ be admitted to an intensive care unit,⁴ or undergo cardiac catheterization,⁵ renal transplantation⁶ or total joint arthroplasty.⁷ Although women''s preferences for surgery or the information needed to make an informed decision may differ from men and explain sex-based differences in care,^8,9 subtle or overt gender bias may inappropriately influence physicians'' clinical decision-making.^2,5,7 A more pronounced gender bias might be expected when the clinical decision involves an elective surgical procedure such as total joint arthroplasty.Total hip and knee arthroplasty is the definitive treatment for relieving pain and restoring function in people with moderate to severe osteoarthritis for whom medical therapy has failed.¹⁰ Although age-adjusted rates of total joint arthroplasty are higher among women than among men,¹¹ based on a population-based epidemiologic survey, underuse of arthroplasty is 3 times greater in women.⁷ In prior opinion surveys, more than 93% of referring physicians and orthopedic surgeons have reported that patients'' sex has no effect on their decision to refer a patient for, or perform, total knee arthroplasty.^12,13 However, there may be a difference between what is reported in a survey and what occurs in clinical practice. The purpose of our study was to determine whether physicians would provide the same recommendation about total knee arthroplasty to a male and a female standardized patient presenting to their offices with identical clinical scenarios that differed only by sex.