Fluctuations in the incubation moisture environment affect growth but not survival of hatchling lizards

Few studies have collected longitudinal data that follow the complete microevolutionary path of an organism linking sources of variation (e.g. environmental versus genetic) to a trait and its subsequent relationship with fitness. Identifying the links within this pathway is imperative for understanding the ecological relevance of effects found at the phenotypic level. Furthermore, experimental studies that examine parts of the pathway in ectothermic organisms often fail to mimic the complexities of the natural developmental environment. Temperature and moisture conditions in reptile nests, for example, can fluctuate greatly on a seasonal and daily basis. Despite the potential effects of fluctuating environments, the vast majority of studies have held environmental treatments constant during the developmental period. We investigated the effects of fluctuating moisture regimes during incubation on eggs, hatchling phenotypes, and subsequent survival in the eastern fence lizard Sceloporus undulatus. Moisture fluctuations during embryonic development caused water absorption by eggs to follow the environmental availability of moisture. Initial hatchling tail length was affected by the pattern of moisture fluctuations, and hatchling growth rates in fluctuating treatments were significantly faster than those in a constant treatment, resulting in larger hatchlings after 4 weeks. A release–recapture experiment conducted in the field did not detect a treatment effect on survival despite the larger body sizes. In summary, although fluctuations affected water absorption by eggs and some hatchling traits, these effects did not have subsequent fitness consequences. The results obtained suggest that egg and hatchling survival are buffered against natural soil moisture fluctuations during incubation, even when egg and hatchling traits are significantly affected. © 2010 The Linnean Society of London, Biological Journal of the Linnean Society, 2010, 100 , 89–102.