A trade-off generated by sexual conflict: Mediterranean wrasse males refuse present mates to increase future success

A variety of mechanisms, including intrasexual competition,intersexual conflict, and physiological constraints, can explainpatterns of reproduction and the adaptive value of specificbehaviors. In a Mediterranean wrasse, Symphodus ocellatus (Labridae),large, nesting males occasionally refuse to spawn with willingfemales in the presence of small, sneaker males. We exploredthe possible adaptive significance of this behavior. Nestingmales refuse females despite the fact that it reduces theirimmediate mating success. This nesting-male behavior also decreasesfemale and sneaker mating success and occurs when sneaker malessurround the nest. Experiments that decreased the number ofsneakers around nests showed that nesting males respond immediatelyto mating opportunities when fewer sneakers are present, andthus they are not simply constrained by a lack of energy orlack of sperm. Experiments that increased the number of sneakersat the nest caused nesting males initially to refuse spawningopportunities, followed by a subsequent decrease in sneakerpresence and an increase in mating rate. We propose that thisbehavior is the result of a trade-off between immediate matingsuccess and future reproduction created by competition betweenmales and conflict between the sexes. Males reduce their immediatemating success by reducing spawning at the nest; sneaker malessubsequently leave, and this decreases mate competition forthe nesting male. Unresponsiveness of nesting males also causessexual conflict between females and nesting males over mating.We argue that this behavior and the existence of a trade-offcan only be understood by examining intersexual conflict andintrasexual competition simultaneously.