Host Cell Detection of Noncoding Stuffer DNA Contained in Helper-Dependent Adenovirus Vectors Leads to Epigenetic Repression of Transgene Expression

Helper-dependent adenovirus (hdAd) vectors have shown great promise as therapeutic gene delivery vehicles in gene therapy applications. However, the level and duration of gene expression from hdAd can differ considerably depending on the nature of the noncoding stuffer DNA contained within the vector. For example, an hdAd containing 22 kb of prokaryotic DNA (hdAd-prok) expresses its transgene 60-fold less efficiently than a similar vector containing eukaryotic DNA (hdAd-euk). Here we have determined the mechanistic basis of this phenomenon. Although neither vector was subjected to CpG methylation and both genomes associated with cellular histones to similar degrees, hdAd-prok chromatin was actively deacetylated. Insertion of an insulator element between the transgene and the bacterial DNA derepressed hdAd-prok, suggesting that foreign DNA nucleates repressive chromatin structures that spread to the transgene. We found that Sp100B/Sp100HMG and Daxx play a role in repressing transgene expression from hdAd and act independently of PML bodies. Thus, we have identified nuclear factors involved in recognizing foreign DNA and have determined the mechanism by which associated genes are repressed.Efficient delivery and expression of foreign genes are of great importance in medicine and basic science. In many gene therapy applications, expression of the therapeutic gene would be required for the lifetime of the patient, yet many vector systems display only transient expression, lasting as little as a few days or weeks. Helper-dependent adenovirus (hdAd) vectors can enhance the duration of expression of a therapeutic gene; studies of mice and nonhuman primates have yielded several years of gene expression after a single administration (28). Indeed, several studies have described lifelong expression of a gene and persistent phenotypic correction in mouse models of human disease (18, 26, 42).Most hdAds contain noncoding “stuffer” DNA to maintain the size of the vector within appropriate limits for efficient DNA packaging; vectors constructed below ∼27 kb undergo DNA rearrangement in order to increase the size of the genome to 27 to 38 kb (31, 38). Interestingly, the nature of the stuffer DNA included in the hdAd has a significant effect on the function of the vector. An hdAd vector containing 22 kb of eukaryotic DNA (hdAd-euk) expressed a transgene to a higher level and for a longer duration than a vector containing 22 kb of prokaryotic DNA (hdAd-prok), both in vitro and in vivo (29). The genomes of the two vectors persisted at similar levels within the livers of transduced mice, suggesting that incorporation of prokaryote-derived stuffer DNA into an hdAd leads to the shutoff of associated transgenes. As a result of these observations, most current hdAd vectors are constructed using stuffer DNA derived from eukaryotic sources (27).Silencing of transgenes associated with prokaryotic DNA is not unique to hdAd. Removal of the bacterial origin of replication and antibiotic resistance gene from herpes simplex virus (HSV) amplicons resulted in a 20-fold improvement in gene expression in normal human fibroblasts in vitro, and more-persistent reporter gene expression in nude mice, compared to amplicons retaining the bacterial elements (39). Similarly, removal of bacterial sequences from plasmids results in significantly improved transgene expression in vitro and in vivo (2, 3, 34). For both plasmid and HSV amplicons, the mechanisms by which the bacterial sequences impair transgene expression are not fully understood. However, the bacterial sequences appear to nucleate the formation of a repressive chromatin structure(s) that spreads to the transgene (4, 39).In this study, we experimentally address the mechanism behind the repressive effects of prokaryotic DNA on gene expression in hdAd vectors. We found that prokaryotic DNA inhibits eukaryotic gene expression in cis, via induction of histone deacetylation, which is independent of DNA methylation. Furthermore, our data indicate that Sp100 and Daxx are involved in repressing the expression of genes associated with prokaryotic DNA.