Estimation of the Size of Genetic Bottlenecks in Cell-to-Cell Movement of Soil-Borne Wheat Mosaic Virus and the Possible Role of the Bottlenecks in Speeding Up Selection of Variations in trans-Acting Genes or Elements

Genetic bottlenecks facilitate the fixation and extinction of variants in populations, and viral populations are no exception to this theory. To examine the existence of genetic bottlenecks in cell-to-cell movement of plant RNA viruses, we prepared constructs for Soil-borne wheat mosaic virus RNA2 vectors carrying two different fluorescent proteins, yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) and cyan fluorescent protein (CFP). Coinoculation of host plant leaves with the two RNA2 vectors and the wild-type RNA1 showed separation of the two vector RNA2s, mostly within seven to nine cell-to-cell movements from individual initially coinfected cells. Our statistical analysis showed that the number of viral RNA genomes establishing infection in adjacent cells after the first cell-to-cell movement from an initially infected cell was 5.97 ± 0.22 on average and 5.02 ± 0.29 after the second cell-to-cell movement. These results indicate that plant RNA viruses may generally face narrow genetic bottlenecks in every cell-to-cell movement. Furthermore, our model suggests that, rather than suffering from fitness losses caused by the bottlenecks, the plant RNA viruses are utilizing the repeated genetic bottlenecks as an essential element of rapid selection of their adaptive variants in trans-acting genes or elements to respond to host shifting and changes in the growth conditions of the hosts.Plant RNA viruses change their genomes so rapidly that variant viruses with altered biological properties are often found after prolonged growth of infected plants or after serial mechanical inoculations (26, 33). Furthermore, inoculation of less-fit artificial mutants produces revertants or pseudo-revertants even after short infection times (12, 14). The rapid evolution of plant RNA viral genomes is achieved not only by high mutation rates due to error-prone replication by the nonproofreading viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (19) but also by rapid selection and strong genetic drift. Generally, narrow genetic bottlenecks facilitate the fixation and extinction of variants in populations (15), and viral populations are no exception to this theory.Plant RNA viruses are known to face many narrow genetic bottlenecks during their life cycles (23). The life cycles of most plant RNA viruses are as follows: After replicating in cells, viruses move from cell to cell through plasmodesmata, which connect the cytoplasms of adjacent cells separated by cell walls in plant tissue. Following the establishment of infection in cells and cell-to-cell movements, the viruses expand their infected regions, spreading to the veins and moving through the vascular system and infecting the plant systemically. Some plant RNA viruses are transmitted through the seeds or via mechanical injuries, but most are transmitted from plant to plant by biological vectors such as insects, nematodes, and fungi. Previous studies have found that genetic bottlenecks occur during the transfer from lower leaves to upper leaves in systemic infections of Wheat streak mosaic virus (WSMV) (11), Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) (24), and Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) (18) and during the transfer from one tiller to another tiller of WSMV (11). Vector transmissions were also shown to act as genetic bottlenecks for WSMV (11), CMV (1, 3), and Potato virus Y (PVY) (20). With the exception of PVY, the typical method for detecting genetic bottlenecks has been to observe the spatial separation of closely related strains or artificial synonymous mutants inoculated as mixed populations: the narrower the genetic bottleneck, the more frequently the spatial separation should be observed. Using this idea with mathematical analyses, WSMV was estimated to infect a new tiller starting with four genomes (9), TMV was estimated to infect the upper leaves starting with 10 genomes (24), and CMV was estimated to infect a new plant starting with one to two particles after aphid transmission (3). Studies of PVY using sets of host plant cultivars with or without resistance genes and mixed strains of viruses with or without resistance-breaking abilities also estimated the number of virus particles transmitted by an aphid vector to be 0.5 to 3.2 on average (20).However, genetic bottlenecks in cell-to-cell movement of viruses have not been well characterized, although these occurrences are likely (11) and have been expected to be important for understanding the life cycle and population dynamics of plant RNA viruses. The size of genetic bottlenecks in cell-to-cell movement can be referred to as “multiplicity of infection (MOI) in plant tissue colonization,” and only a recent study showing that the estimated MOI of TMV is between 6 and 1 to 2 (10) indicates the occurrence and the size of genetic bottlenecks in cell-to-cell movement of a plant RNA virus. In this paper, we also show the occurrence of narrow genetic bottlenecks during cell-to-cell movement of a plant RNA virus, Soil-borne wheat mosaic virus (SBWMV, type species of the genus Furovirus), by observing the spatial separation of RNA2 vectors carrying different fluorescent proteins, yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) and cyan fluorescent protein (CFP). Both of the fluorescent proteins were expressed as fusion proteins to the N-terminal nuclear localization signal (NLS) peptide from Simian virus 40 (SV40) large T antigen, which enabled us to observe and count the infected cells accurately using nuclear fluorescence. Numerical data were analyzed to estimate the size of bottlenecks. We also carried out a simulation to show that, due to the narrow genetic bottlenecks, rapid selection occurs even on trans-acting elements in plant RNA virus genomes, overcoming the negative effect of complementation among adaptive and defective genomes in each intracellular population. We discuss the possible roles of the bottlenecks in the life cycle and evolution mechanisms of plant RNA viruses.