Cost of reproduction and the evolution of deferred breeding in the western gull

Survival patterns in a population of western gulls (Larus occidentalis)of known age of first breeding, a, indicate a cost of reproductionrelated to the age of initial breeding. Among both sexes, birdsthat commenced breeding at the earliest ages (3 years in malesand 4 years in females) had higher annual mortality than thosethat deferred breeding one or more years. In addition, females(but not males) evidenced a cumulative cost of reproduction:holding age constant, females with more annual breeding attemptsdemonstrated poorer survival. These patterns of -specific survivalwere statistically significant after controlling for interannualvariation in food availability and are not explained simplyby variation in the intrinsic quality of individuals. To assessthe effects of these sex-specific costs on fitness, we combinedthe observed survival patterns with data on prebreeding survivorshipand -specific reproductive success to estimate rates of populationgrowth and lifetime reproductive success for different agesat first reproduction. Males showed a clearly defined fitnessoptimum at = 4 years, which coincided with the modal for malesin the population. Females showed no clear optimum, except thatbreeding at age 4 was suboptimal, hence females benefited fromdeferring breeding to ages 5-7 years. Observed age of firstbreeding also showed no clear mode for females, with slightpeaks at ages 5 and 7. As a result, in both sexes, the fitnesssurface for corresponded well with observed frequencies of. We suggest that stabilizing selection has acted to shape thephenotypic distribution of in males but, due to trade-offsbetween survival and early reproduction, stabilizing selectionis weak or absent in females