Differentiation of Shigella strains by plasmid profile analysis, serotyping and phage typing

Ninety-one Shigella flexneri and 29 Shigella sonnei strains isolated during 1994 from sporadic cases of shigellosis and healthy carriers were analyzed for plasmid profile in order to compare the discriminating ability of this method with that of serotyping and phage typing. Our study revealed 10 plasmid profiles (PP) among S. sonnei strains. A total of 26 out of 29 (89%) S. sonnei isolates could be placed into two phage types (type 1 and 20) comprising four PP for phage type 1 and seven PP for type 20, respectively. Twenty-three different PP were identified among S. flexneri strains. Each serotype was associated with a specific predominant plasmid profile, except serotype 2a. This serotype, the most frequently isolated in Romania, was still rather homogeneous: 33 out of 39 isolates belonged to phage type 125, 27 of which could be placed into two related PP (F10 and F17). Comparison of plasmid patterns of epidemiologically independent S. flexneri serotype 2a isolates with those exhibited by 45 serotype 2a isolates associated to six independent outbreaks revealed the same homogeneity. Thirty-eight strains, representing 4 of 6 outbreaks, had F10 and F17 plasmid patterns. The discrimination indices (D) for plasmid profile analysis alone (D = 0.890) and for the combination of serotyping and phage typing (D = 0.841) indicate that both typing systems have a nearly similar ability of discriminating among S. flexneri strains. By combining the results of the three typing methods, a total of 42 types are distinguished and the D value is 0.942. Our data suggest that plasmid profile analysis can complement phenotyping methods resulting in a degree of discrimination that cannot be achieved by either system alone.