Risk-Based Management of Site Soils Contaminated with a Mixture of Hazardous Substances: Methodological Approach and Case Study

A novel approach to improve the accuracy and to reduce the uncertainty associated with the assessment of ecotoxicological risks and the determination of remedial objectives was developed herein for a scenario involving multiple contaminants in soil. This approach used laboratory-derived site-specific toxicological data (i.e., obtained from toxicity testing using species in direct contact with soil such as plants and invertebrates) instead of the more traditional approach using generic toxicological benchmarks for corresponding groups of organisms. Inherent to this approach were the data exploration and reduction; the use of generalized linear models to integrate the data for stressors (site-specific chemical and edaphic characteristics with the potential for influencing toxicity) and effects (biological responses for multiple species and multiple endpoints); and the derivation of tools that could predict the level of impairment associated with any combination of metals’ concentrations measured on site and compare it to a pre-specified acceptable threshold. A case study is presented whereby this method was applied to a large site contaminated with a mixture of metals. Ultimately, the distributions of predicted levels of risk for both soil invertebrates and plants were determined for the entire site and compared to those obtained using the traditional approach using benchmarks.