Reconstruction of adaptive radiation in insular habitats using integrated biogeographic information

Aim To develop an analytical method for accurately reconstructing the biogeographic events associated with adaptive radiation in a system of insular habitats. Location An idealized, two-dimensional model system of insular habitats is based on the altitudinally stratified vegetation zones on the island-like mountains of eastern Africa. Methods The model system is treated as a two-dimensional array of insular habitats, and adaptive radiation is treated as a ‘space-filling’ process according to six premises based on uniformitarian principles. Previous approaches to this class of problems have used (1) Hennig's progression rule, (2) optimization of biogeographic character states, and (3) reasoned argumentation with an intuitive synthesis of information. The strengths and limitations of these previous approaches are evaluated. Results A closed analytical method is presented that accurately reconstructs biogeographic events. This methodological approach integrates atomized information back up to the appropriate level of biological organization and has general applicability to phylogenetic analysis. Main conclusions In a truly evolutionary approach to phylogenetic systematics and biogeography, the initial analysis of the pattern of descent should be complemented with a subsequent analysis of the pattern of modification. The method presented here offers one approach to analysing the pattern of modification, which in this case constitutes biogeographic movement.