Photosynthetic traits in C3 and C4 grassland species in mesocosm and field environments

The North American tallgrass prairie is composed of a diverse mix of C₃ and C₄ plant species that are subject to multiple resource limitations. C₄ grasses dominate this ecosystem, purportedly due to greater photosynthetic capacity and resource-use efficiency associated with C₄ photosynthesis. We tested the hypothesis that intrinsic physiological differences between C₃ and C₄ species are consistent with C₄ grass dominance by comparing leaf gas exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence variables for seven C₄ and C₃ herbaceous species (legumes and non-legumes) in two different settings: experimental mesocosms and natural grassland sites. In the mesocosms, C₄ grasses had higher photosynthetic rates, water potentials and water-use efficiency than the C₃ species. These differences were absent in the field, where photosynthetic rates declined similarly among non-leguminous species. Thus, intrinsic photosynthetic advantages for C₄ species measured in resource-rich mesocosms could not explain the dominance of C₄ species in the field. Instead, C₄ dominance in this ecosystem may depend more on the ability of the grasses to grow rapidly when resources are plentiful and to tolerate multiple limitations when resources are scarce.