Pursuit of Heterospecific Targets by Territorial Amberwing Dragonflies (Perithemis tenera Say): A Case of Mistaken Identity

Although they are defending mating territories, territory residents of a wide variety of insect species have been observed to pursue heterospecifics in addition to the conspecifics that intrude on their territories. One species that has such heterospecific pursuits is the Eastern amberwing dragonfly (Perithemis tenera Say) (Anisoptera: Libellulidae). In this study, we tested five alternative hypotheses for the function of heterospecific pursuits in amberwings: competition for resources, prevention of interference while mating, predator deterrence, foraging, and mistaken identity. Resident males pursued both male and female conspecifics, as well as a species of horse fly (Tabanus spp.) and butterfly (Ancyloxypha numitor). Other intruding odonates, including Epitheca princeps, Erythemis simplicicollis, Libellula luctuosa, Pachydiplax longipennis, and Plathemis lydia, were relatively ignored. Because the horse fly and butterfly were similar to amberwings in body size, color, and flight height, and because they are not predators or prey of amberwings, we concluded that the pursuit of these heterospecifics was due to mistaken identity. The characteristics of the horsefly and butterfly likely correspond to the cues that the male amberwings use to identify conspecifics, and the relative rarity of intrusions by these two species (as well as by female amberwings) probably made it more costly to discriminate and pursue only conspecifics than to make some mistaken pursuits.