Carbon isotopic abundances in Mesozoic and Cenozoic fossil plants: Palaeoecological implications

Carbon isotopic abundances have been measured for more than one hundred samples of fossil plants ranging in age from middle Triassic to late Tertiary. Most of the plant fossils were identified at the specific or generic level and were selected as representing a variety of continental environments, including xeric and humid habitats. Material analysed included numerous fragments of flowers, seeds, fruits, leaves and wood, as well as a single amorphous lignite sample. The analyses performed for the plant fragments indicate relatively constant isotopic compositions during this time interval, with plant δ¹³C values ranging between -28 and -20%. These values are within the range for living terrestrial plants with C₃, photosynthesis, although values more positive than -23% are rare in C₃ plants and typically found in plants growing under environmental stress. Lower δ¹³C values might have been expected owing to the much higher CO₂, levels of the Cretaceous atmosphere that have been inferred from marine carbonates. No fossils with values indicating C₄, photosynthesis were discovered. Fossil plants from inferred mesic environments showed δ¹³C values ranging between -26.7 and -24.1%. Highest δ¹³C values in angiosperms (up to -20.1%) were measured for Late Cretaceous combretaceous flowers from Portugal. Some cheirolepidiaceous conifers from the Early Cretaceous also showed high δ¹³C values. Values measured for Pseudofrenelopsis varians and Glenrosa taxensis were -21.9%, and values of gymnosperm wood, probably of cheirolepidiaceous affinity, were -19.0%. These high values are in accordance with inferred ecological conditions for the fossil plants. They may suggest a tendency for C₄,-like photosynthesis, although the data are equivocal. Higher values (-17.3%) clearly falling outside the C₃, range were, however, obtained from a single lignite fragment of Late Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) age. The nature of this plant fragment is unknown, but the result suggests that C₄-like photosynthesis was present at least in some latest Cretaceous vegetation. A hadrosaurian dinosaur with well-preserved collagen-like organic matter from the same deposit showed δ¹³C values around-16%, which also suggests the presence of CAM or even C₄ plants in the latest Cretaceous. □Carbon isotopic abundances, δ¹³C values, dinosaurs, plants, photosynthetic pathways, Mesozoic.