Structural sensitivity of grazing formulations in nutrient controlled plankton models

Summary Stability and persistence properties of a family of non-spatial plankton models, each differentiated by its herbivore grazing term, are analytically compared. The dynamic persistence function in the model is shown to operate uniformly even though stability configuration characteristics of the model may be topologically distinct. The persistence threshold for each model indicates that total nutrient is a fundamental biological control. In the parameter space, all of the models studied are structurally unstable; however, an important bifurcation mechanism associated with this instability governs persistence. While, topologically, model transfigurement through parameter modulation is non-continuous, the biological populations evolve in a continuous or a lower semicontinuous manner. A basic conclusion of the paper is that fundamental problems for these marine ecological models remain unresolved since each of the models is a structurally unstable system for a fixed dynamically persistent ecology.