Caterpillars' compensatory feeding response to diluted nutrients leads to toxic allelochemical dose

Many herbivores increase their consumption rate as dietary nutrient concentration declines. This compensatory response can mitigate the fitness-lowering impact of reduced food quality, but little is known about its costs. In this study we tested the hypothesis that one cost to a faster consumption rate can be the ingestion of a toxic dose of an allelochemical occurring in the food. We fed velvetbean caterpillars a diet with progressively diluted nutrient levels but containing the same concentration (% fresh mass, fm) of caffeine, a methylxanthine alkaloid. Larvae compensated for the reduced nutrient level, with those fed the most diluted diet increasing their biomass-relative consumption rate (fm) 2.6-fold over larvae fed the undiluted diet. Consequently, their rate of caffeine ingestion increased to a pharmacologically effective dose, interfering with food utilization, slowing growth, reducing subsequent feeding and lowering survival. These results suggest that greater allelochemical ingestion can be one cost of an increased consumption rate, although additional studies with other allelochemicals and species are necessary to more broadly evaluate whether insects can adaptively balance their intake of nutrients and allelochemicals through adjustments in consumption rate. In addition, these results highlight the importance of measuring consumption rates of allelochemicals and other ingested biocides, not just their dietary concentration, when assessing efficacy against herbivores.