Beneficial Effect of Verminephrobacter Nephridial Symbionts on the Fitness of the Earthworm Aporrectodea tuberculata

Almost all lumbricid earthworms (Oligochaeta: Lumbricidae) harbor species-specific Verminephrobacter (Betaproteobacteria) symbionts in their nephridia (excretory organs). The function of the symbiosis, and whether the symbionts have a beneficial effect on their earthworm host, is unknown; however, the symbionts have been hypothesized to enhance nitrogen retention in earthworms. The effect of Verminephrobacter on the life history traits of the earthworm Aporrectodea tuberculata (Eisen) was investigated by comparing the growth, development, and fecundity of worms with and without symbionts given high (cow dung)- and low (straw)-nutrient diets. There were no differences in worm growth or the number of cocoons produced by symbiotic and aposymbiotic worms. Worms with Verminephrobacter symbionts reached sexual maturity earlier and had higher cocoon hatching success than worms cured of their symbionts when grown on the low-nutrient diet. Thus, Verminephrobacter nephridial symbionts do have a beneficial effect on their earthworm host. Cocoons with and without symbionts did not significantly differ in total organic carbon, total nitrogen, or total hydrolyzable amino acid content, which strongly questions the hypothesized role of the symbionts in nitrogen recycling for the host.Symbiosis has long been recognized as a source of evolutionary innovation (24), and the acquisition of symbionts can enable animal hosts to exploit previously inaccessible niches (3). The phylum Annelida is no exception to this; chemosynthetic symbionts in marine annelids (e.g., the giant tubeworm Riftia sp. and other gutless marine oligochaetes [9]) gain energy from the oxidation of reduced sulfur compounds and fix CO₂ and supply their animal host with fixed carbon. A more obscure partnership is known from the bone-eating annelid Osedax sp., where endosymbionts help degrade the bones of whale carcasses, the only known habitat of the worms (33). The medicinal leech Hirudo sp., like other blood-feeding animals (3, 7), has symbionts that are thought to produce essential vitamins missing from a blood meal (13). In addition, leeches have a number of symbionts of unknown function in their nephridia (excretory organs) (18). Earthworms (Oligochaeta: Lumbricidae) have also long been known to harbor symbiotic bacteria in their nephridia (19, 36). The function of this symbiosis, however, is still not known, but the stability of the symbiosis over evolutionary time (23) suggests that the symbionts benefit the host.The earthworm symbionts reside in the nephridia and have therefore been proposed to be involved in internal recycling of nitrogen in the host (29). The earthworm nephridia play an important role in both nitrogenous waste excretion and osmoregulation (20). The nephridia are found in pairs in each segment of the worm and consist of a coiled tube leading from the coelom to the exterior (Fig. ​(Fig.1).1). The tube forms three loops, and the symbiotic bacteria are situated in the ampulla in the second loop, where they form a dense population lining the lumen wall (19, 36).Open in a separate windowFIG. 1.The nephridia are found as paired organs in each segment of the worm. The nephridostome (the inlet to the nephridia) protrudes into the previous segment. The nephridial tube forms three loops and finally empties out through the body wall via the nephridopore. The symbionts (black) reside in the ampulla in the second loop. (Modified from reference 23 with permission.)The symbionts form the monophyletic genus Verminephrobacter (Betaproteobacteria) (30, 36); they are species specific and present in almost all lumbricid earthworms (23). The Verminephrobacter symbionts are transmitted vertically via the cocoon, where they are deposited along with eggs and sperm (5). During embryogenesis, the symbionts migrate into the developing nephridia, and after the worm hatches, the symbionts can no longer infect (5, 6). By taking advantage of the vertical transmission mode, it has been possible to establish symbiont-free earthworm cultures in the laboratory through controlled antibiotic treatment of newly deposited cocoons (5; this study). Separation of the symbiotic partners allows studies of the effect of the symbionts on their earthworm hosts.Pandazis (29) hypothesized that the symbionts enhance earthworm nitrogen retention by excreting proteolytic enzymes that will degrade peptides and proteins lost in urine; this would allow the earthworm to reabsorb the resulting amino acids. As a consequence, earthworms cured of their symbionts should have a lower fitness level than control worms when grown under nitrogen-limiting conditions. To test this hypothesis, growth, development, fecundity, and cocoon hatching success were compared for symbiotic and aposymbiotic earthworms of the species Aporrectodea tuberculata (Eisen) under high and low nutrient availability conditions.