Analyses of Current-Generating Mechanisms of Shewanella loihica PV-4 and Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 in Microbial Fuel Cells

Although members of the genus Shewanella have common features (e.g., the presence of decaheme c-type cytochromes [c-cyts]), they are widely variable in genetic and physiological features. The present study compared the current-generating ability of S. loihica PV-4 in microbial fuel cells (MFCs) with that of well-characterized S. oneidensis MR-1 and examined the roles of c-cyts in extracellular electron transfer. We found that strains PV-4 and MR-1 exhibited notable differences in current-generating mechanisms. While the MR-1 MFCs maintained a constant current density over time, the PV-4 MFCs continued to increase in current density and finally surpassed the MR-1 MFCs. Coulombic efficiencies reached 26% in the PV-4 MFC but 16% in the MR-1 MFCs. Although both organisms produced quinone-like compounds, anode exchange experiments showed that anode-attached cells of PV-4 produced sevenfold more current than planktonic cells in the same chamber, while planktonic cells of MR-1 produced twice the current of the anode-attached cells. Examination of the genome sequence indicated that PV-4 has more c-cyt genes in the metal reductase-containing locus than MR-1. Mutational analysis revealed that PV-4 relied predominantly on a homologue of the decaheme c-cyt MtrC in MR-1 for current generation, even though it also possesses two homologues of the decaheme c-cyt OmcA in MR-1. These results suggest that current generation in a PV-4 MFC is in large part accomplished by anode-attached cells, in which the MtrC homologue constitutes the main path of electrons toward the anode.Some species of dissimilatory metal-reducing bacteria (DMRB) are able to reduce solid metal oxides as terminal electron acceptors and generate currents in microbial fuel cells (MFCs) (2, 11, 14, 30, 46). Although mixed cultures are often used in MFC experiments (13), studies seeking a mechanistic understanding of electron transfer to electrode surfaces typically target pure cultures of such DMRB, due to the complexity in microbial communities. Presently, two model DMRB, Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 and Geobacter sulfurreducens PCA (2, 3, 12, 18, 31), are used in most investigations.S. oneidensis MR-1 is a metabolically diverse DMRB that has been studied extensively for its potential use in bioremediation applications. For this reason, MR-1 was the first Shewanella species to have its genome completely sequenced and annotated (10). In addition, since the first report in 1999 when this microorganism was shown to have the ability to transfer electrons to the electrode without an exogenously added mediator (14), it has also become one of the model organisms for the study of electron transfer mechanisms in MFCs.Although the molecular mechanisms for extracellular electron transfer have not yet been elucidated fully, c-type cytochromes (c-cyts) appear to be the key cellular components involved in this process (38). In S. oneidensis MR-1, OmcA and MtrC are outer membrane (OM), decaheme c-cyts that are considered to be involved in the direct (directly attached) electron transfer to solid metal oxides and anodes of MFCs (9, 20, 22, 23, 47). Several pieces of evidence suggest that OmcA and MtrC form a complex and act in a cooperative manner (33, 37, 42), and these results correlate with the fact that the genes encoding these proteins constitute an operon-like cluster in the chromosome (1). It has also been shown that MtrC and OmcA have overlapping functions as terminal reductases of metal oxides (25, 38). OmcA and MtrC are also present on the surface of nanowires and may be involved in the long-range transfer of electrons (8). In addition to direct electron transfer, MR-1 has the ability to produce water-soluble electron-shuttle compounds (quinones and flavins) that are involved in the mediated electron transfer from cells to distant solid electron acceptors (metal oxides or MFC anodes) (21, 27, 44).Recently, the genome sequences of nearly 20 Shewanella strains have been completed and annotated, opening the door to study the diversity of their extracellular electron transfer mechanisms. A comparison of their genomes has shown that although they have some consensus OM c-cyt genes, variations exist in the number and order of these genes in their metal reductase-containing loci (6). One such species is S. loihica strain PV-4, which was recently isolated from an iron-rich microbial mat near a deep-sea hydrothermal vent located on the Loihi Seamount in Hawaii (7, 32). The phenotypic and phylogenetic characteristics of PV-4 were determined, with a subsequent study focusing on the metal reduction and iron biomineralization capabilities of this bacterium (32). Initial experiments performed in our laboratory revealed that PV-4 developed a c-cyt-dependent deep red color that was much more striking than that of strain MR-1 when grown anaerobically with iron oxide as the terminal electron acceptor (26). This allowed us to assume that PV-4 could have a high extracellular electron transfer ability. Accordingly, the present study evaluated the current-producing ability of strain PV-4 in MFCs and examined the roles of some c-cyts in extracellular electron transfer. Special attention was paid to the comparison of PV-4 with MR-1 to reveal differences in mechanisms for extracellular electron transfer. We report herein differences between these strains in the roles of OM c-cyts for extracellular electron transfer, the behaviors and metabolic patterns of MFC, and the resultant MFC performances.