Homologous recombination in Agrobacterium: potential implications for the genomic species concept in bacteria

According to current taxonomical rules, a bona fide bacterialspecies is a genomic species characterized by the genomic similarityof its members. It has been proposed that the genomic cohesionof such clusters may be related to sexual isolation, which limitsgene flow between too divergent bacteria. Homologous recombinationis one of the most studied mechanisms responsible for this geneticisolation. Previous studies on several bacterial models showedthat recombination frequencies decreased exponentially withincreasing DNA sequence divergence. In the present study, weinvestigated this relationship in the Agrobacterium tumefaciensspecies complex, which allowed us to focus on sequence divergencein the vicinity of the genetic boundaries of genomic species.We observed that the sensitivity of the recombination frequencyto DNA divergence fitted a log-linear function until approximately10% sequence divergence. The results clearly revealed that therewas no sharp drop in recombination frequencies at the pointwhere the sequence divergence distribution showed a "gap" delineatinggenomic species. The ratio of the recombination frequency inhomogamic conditions relative to this frequency in heterogamicconditions, that is, sexual isolation, was found to decreasefrom 8 between the most distant strains within a species to9 between the most closely related species, for respective increasesfrom 4.3% to 6.4% mismatches in the marker gene chvA. This meansthat there was only a 1.13-fold decrease in recombination frequenciesfor recombination events at both edges of the species border.Hence, from the findings of this investigation, we concludethat—at least in this taxon—sexual isolation basedon homologous recombination is likely not high enough to stronglyhamper gene flow between species as compared with gene flowbetween distantly related members of the same species. The 70%relative binding ratio cutoff used to define bacterial speciesis likely correlated to only minor declines in homologous recombinationfrequencies. Consequently, the sequence diversity, as a mechanisticfactor for the efficiency of recombination (as assayed in thelaboratory), appears to play little role in the genetic cohesionof bacterial species, and thus, the genomic species definitionfor prokaryotes is definitively not reconcilable with the biologicalspecies concept for eukaryotes.