Non-phytotoxicity of the aluminum sulfate ion, AlSO+4

Aluminum is a phytotoxic element in many soils and occurs in a variety of chemical species. In order to determine whether AlSO⁺₄ is toxic, seedlings of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv. Tyler) and red clover (Trifolium pratense L. cv. Kenland) were transferred to solutions containing controlled activities of Al³⁺, AlSO⁺₄, Na⁺ and Ca²⁺. Root elongation was inhibited by Al³⁺ (or mononuclear hydroxy-Al species that are in equilibrium with Al³⁺), but not by AlSO⁺₄. We assumed a formation constant (K_AlSO⁺₄= {AlSO⁺₄}/[{Al³⁺} {SO^2-₄}]; braces indicate activities} of 10^3.2 for AlSO⁺₄ in the computation of ionic activities, but use of K_AlSO⁺₄ values ranging from 10^2.8 to 10^3.6 had very little effect on the computed toxicities of Al³⁺ and AlSO⁺₄. Sulfate did not promote the formation of polynuclear Al complexes in our experiments. A practice in studies of Al phytotoxicity has been to attribute toxicity to mononuclear Al, but now it would seem advisable to exclude AlSO⁺₄. That AlSO⁺₄ is non-toxic, or is at least 10-fold less toxic than Al³⁺, has implications for the physiology of Al toxicity and for the use of sulfate salts in experimental work and in agriculture.