Artificial nest site preferences of Black-capped Chickadees

ABSTRACT.   To facilitate study of the breeding biology of parids, Grubb and Bronson (1995; Condor 97: 1067–1070) designed artificial "snags" made from polyvinyl chloride (PVC) tubes. Because the cost of artificial snags is greater than that of traditional wooden boxes, we examined alternatives to PVC snags for attracting chickadees to artificial nesting sites. From 2005 to 2007, we compared the use of PVC snags and wooden nest boxes by Black-capped Chickadees ( Poecile atricapillus ) in Sapsucker Woods Sanctuary in Ithaca, New York. We also quantified the use of cavities with and without wood shavings. The probability of chickadee excavation was greater (60–70% per yr) in filled snags (with wood shavings) than in filled boxes (40–50%; logistic mixed model, P = 0.01), and chickadees initiated more nests in filled snags (25–30%) than filled boxes (15%; P = 0.03). Chickadees also initiated significantly more nests ( P = 0.03) in filled than unfilled boxes. Although wooden boxes filled with wood shavings were used more often by Black-capped Chickadees than unfilled wooden boxes, artificial snags filled with wood shavings were used most, were no more likely than boxes to be usurped by House Wrens ( Troglodytes aedon ), and were less likely than boxes to be occupied by mice. Thus, artificial snags may be the better option for investigators studying the breeding biology of chickadees.