Intraspecific variability in rhynchonellid brachiopods: test of a competition hypothesis

The variability in the plicae of the central fold of eight rhynchonellid brachiopods – Lepidocyclus capax (Ordovician), Stegerhynchus whitii (Silurian), Megalopterorhynchus baldwini (Devonian), 'Camarotoechia' purduei (Mississippian), Wellerella osagensis (Pennsylvanian), Leiorhynchus weeksi (Permian), 'Pugnoides'; Iriassicus (Triassic) and Tetrarhynchia sp. (Jurassic) – is inversely related to the diversity of brachiopods within the faunal assemblage. Explanations for the phenotypic variability due to taxonomic splitting, sexual polymorphism or ontogenetic development are precluded or unsupported by the morphologic analysis, although a small percentage of the morphologic variability can be ascribed to ecophenotypic differentiation by environmental stimuli.
After considerations of the abiotic influences of time, geographic location and isolation, and environmental stability and homogeneity, most of the morphologic variability in these brachiopods is attributed to the biotic influence, namely competition. Other proposed relationships, i.e. population abundance, sample size, shell size or ribbing pattern and intraspecific variability are not statistically significant.