Co-diversity and co-distribution in phyllostomid bats: Evaluating the relative roles of climate and niche conservatism

Explaining the causes of geographic gradients in biodiversity remains an elusive task. Traditionally, correlative approaches have been used to relate species richness with contemporary climate, without actually explaining the causal factors. Recent approaches propose simulation models as more appropriate tools for assessing potential causes of macroecological patterns. Here we developed stochastic models to assess the relative contribution of climate and niche conservatism in determining compositional similarity among sites (co-diversity) and geographic association among species (co-distribution) in the bat family Phyllostomidae. We used range-diversity plots and variance-ratio tests to describe and evaluate such patterns. Our results supported a strong effect of climate in determining cohesive ranges causing positive co-diversity and co-distribution. We also demonstrated a marginal effect of niche conservatism, as modeled here, among species in shaping these patterns. However, climate and niche conservatism are not sufficient and other processes are still required to explain observed patterns. Our study highlights the importance of historical processes and demonstrates the usefulness of a simulation framework in testing biogeographical hypothesis to understand the relationship between diversity and distribution.