Mechanisms of lymphocyte "deletion" by high concentrations of ligand. I. Cyclic AMP levels and cell death in T-lymphocytes exposed to high concentrations of concanavalin A

DNA synthesis, cell survival, and cyclic AMP (cAMP) levels were compared in whole and purified lymph node cells (LNC) cultured with optimal (5 μg/ml) and excess (200 μg/ml) concentrations of native (N) or succinyl (S) concanavalin A (Con A) as possible models for antigen-induced lymphocyte activation and “high-dose” tolerance. Whole LNC cultured with optimal N-Con A or S-Con A showed continuing DNA synthesis and cell viability between 30 and 50% at 48 hr. In contrast, with excess N-Con A, they showed virtually no ³H]TdR uptake at this time and there was progressive loss of cell viability beginning at 8 hr; by 48 hr almost no viable cells remained. Excess S-Con A induced little cell death up to 24 hr, but by 48 hr only 20% of the cells initially placed in culture remained alive and sythesized DNA. Intracellular cAMP showed a transient rise in cultures stimulated with optimal N-Con A, peaking at 15 min, then returning to normal levels, to rise again between 24 and 48 hr. With excess N-Con A, cAMP rose within 15 min and continued to increase to a peak at 24 hr. cAMP levels in the presence of excess S-Con A remained at control levels for the first 24 hr and increased between 24 and 48 hr. LNC depleted of macrophages and B cells, when cultured in excess N-Con A, had an inhibition of DNA synthesis, elevated cAMP levels, and cell death comparable to whole LNC. It seems unlikely, however, that the increase in cAMP mediates cell killing since cAMP was not elevated yet cell death occurred in nylon wool-purified T cells exposed to excess N-Con A. Dibutyryl cAMP, and prostaglandin E₁, which markedly increase cAMP levels, failed to kill LNC at doses which totally inhibited DNA synthesis, and cells of the mouse T-lymphoma S49 and its cAMP-dependent protein kinase-deficient variant were killed equally by excess N-Con A. It is suggested that a sustained elevation of either cAMP or Ca²⁺ after early commitment may provide a significant mechanism of tolerogenesis.