Molecular phylogeny of the antitropical genus Pseudolabrus (Perciformes: Labridae): evidence for a Southern Hemisphere origin

The genus Pseudolabrus comprises 11 species of marine nearshore fishes which are antitropically distributed: two species occur in East Asia, the remaining nine species being distributed in the Southern Hemisphere, mainly in the temperate Pacific. The distributions of their closely allied genera, collectively called "pseudolabrines" are, however, restricted to the Australia-New Zealand region. The molecular phylogeny of six of the 11 Pseudolabrus species from both Hemispheres and four of the five other pseudolabrine genera was reconstructed from nucleotide sequence data from mitochondrial DNA 12S rRNA, tRNAVal, and 16S rRNA genes. Both parsimony and Bayesian analyses were performed. Results are not consistent with a previous phylogenetic hypothesis based on osteological data, particularly in the relationship between Pseudolabrus and Notolabrus, indicating a probable need for reviewing the status of Notolabrus (or the delimitations of both Pseudolabrus and Notolabrus). The two Northern Hemisphere species of Pseudolabrus were monophyletic and nested deep into the clade of the Southern Hemisphere pseudolabrines, which indicates that both pseudolabrines and Pseudolabrus originated in the Southern Hemisphere. A dispersal rather than vicariance explanation for the antitropical distribution of Pseudolabrus is more parsimonious given the number of dispersal events, extinctions, and evolutionary adaptations required under the phylogeny. Based on molecular clock calibrations, the transequatorial divergence was suggested to be early to mid Pliocene at the earliest.