Experimental Adaptation of Burkholderia cenocepacia to Onion Medium Reduces Host Range

It is unclear whether adaptation to a new host typically broadens or compromises host range, yet the answer bears on the fate of emergent pathogens and symbionts. We investigated this dynamic using a soil isolate of Burkholderia cenocepacia, a species that normally inhabits the rhizosphere, is related to the onion pathogen B. cepacia, and can infect the lungs of cystic fibrosis patients. We hypothesized that adaptation of B. cenocepacia to a novel host would compromise fitness and virulence in alternative hosts. We modeled adaptation to a specific host by experimentally evolving 12 populations of B. cenocepacia in liquid medium composed of macerated onion tissue for 1,000 generations. The mean fitness of all populations increased by 78% relative to the ancestor, but significant variation among lines was observed. Populations also varied in several phenotypes related to host association, including motility, biofilm formation, and quorum-sensing function. Together, these results suggest that each population adapted by fixing different sets of adaptive mutations. However, this adaptation was consistently accompanied by a loss of pathogenicity to the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans; by 500 generations most populations became unable to kill nematodes. In conclusion, we observed a narrowing of host range as a consequence of prolonged adaptation to an environment simulating a specific host, and we suggest that emergent pathogens may face similar consequences if they become host-restricted.Some emergent pathogens, such as Pseudomonas and Burkholderia species, persist in a wide range of plant and animal hosts, suggesting that the virulence factors needed to infect plants and animals are similar (5, 40). Yet whether adaptation to a new niche tends to compromise niche breadth or, in this case, host range is an open question. Adaptation to a novel host may restrict host range to various degrees, whether by diminishing host-specific virulence traits without affecting host colonization or by reducing the ability to initiate infection in alternative hosts. However, if factors needed to colonize plant and animal hosts are similar, then why are some bacterial populations restricted to a narrow host range while others are not? One explanation for a limited host range may be the result of genetic trade-offs associated with adaptation to a specific host (7, 18). Another explanation may be that prolonged adaptation to a specific host casts a “selective shadow” over unused functions that are relevant to colonizing other hosts but decay by genetic drift (7, 18). To address these possibilities, we quantified the direct and correlated effects of specific host adaptation by the opportunistic pathogen Burkholderia cenocepacia.Members of the Burkholderia cepacia complex (Bcc), which are ubiquitous in the environment, were once used as biocontrol and bioremedial agents but now are banned from these applications because of the potential of some members to cause plant and human disease (39). The type species B. cepacia is well known as a pathogen of the common yellow onion, Allium cepa, in which it causes a characteristic yellow or brown rot. Another species, B. cenocepacia, can also infect onions as well as a range of plants and animals, including humans (2, 6, 26, 36). Bcc bacteria can cause serious infection in the lungs of cystic fibrosis (CF) patients (6, 26). These infections, called “cepacia syndrome,” are highly contagious among CF patients, and infections produce many negative effects on an already poor quality of life, including longer hospital stays, removal from lung transplant lists, blood poisoning, and eventual death (24). B. cenocepacia, one of the two Bcc species most commonly isolated from lung infections, is especially threatening and is associated with more severe cepacia syndrome (35). However, the mechanisms allowing B. cenocepacia to adapt to colonize both human and plant hosts are unclear. Several putative virulence mechanisms have been identified by random mutagenic screens or by knockouts of candidate genes (2, 12, 20, 25, 29, 35, 43, 46), but these mechanisms generally have not been shown to function in host adaptation. One way to directly study adaptation of bacterial populations to susceptible hosts is by experimental evolution, in which bacterial populations evolve in a controlled laboratory setting that enables study of the adaptive process over time (7).We experimentally evolved populations of B. cenocepacia HI2424 to study the extent to which adaptation to the common yellow onion A. cepa affects host range. B. cenocepacia HI2424 is a soil isolate and is classified as part of the PHDC strain lineage, the strain first characterized as responsible for an outbreak of Bcc infections in large treatment centers located in the mid-Atlantic region of the United States (33). We found that adaptation of B. cenocepacia to the onion model was associated with reduced virulence but did not compromise the capacity to colonize (or be consumed by) the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, and the coincidence of these events suggests that a genetic trade-off (antagonistic pleiotropy) between fitness in onion medium and nematode virulence exists. We also characterized several phenotypes potentially associated with adaptation to the onion or nematode virulence. Most phenotypes varied significantly among replicate populations, suggesting that adaptation to the onion model may follow several different pathways.