Semiquantitative assessment of c-erbB-2 (HER-2) status in cytology specimens and tissue sections from breast carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether various methods of fixation of surgical pathology specimens from breast carcinomas would influence the outcome of evaluation of the expression levels of c-erbB-2 (HER-2). For this, comparisons were made between (1) alcohol-fixed (95%) and air-dried smears from fresh surgical pathology specimens of breast carcinomas, and (2) formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections of the same specimens. STUDY DESIGN: Alcohol-fixed and air-dried smears or touch preparations were made from 30 fresh mastectomy/lumpectomy surgical pathology specimens from breast carcinomas. Immunohistochemistry was performed using the c-erbB-2 primary antibody against the extracellular domain of the c-erbB-2 gene product. Staining was simultaneously performed on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue sections of the same specimens. A semiquantitative approach was used for evaluation of immunostaining by three independent investigators, and a consensus was reached. RESULTS: A total of 30 cases were reviewed. Tissue positivity was determined for c-erbB-2 in: 73% of alcohol-fixed specimens (n = 13 3+] and n = 9 2+]), 67% of air-dried smears (n = 9 +3] and n = 11 +2]) and 47% (n = 8 +3]) and n = 6 +2]) of formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue specimens. All formalin-fixed tissue specimens that were determined to positively express c-erbB-2 were also found to be positive on the alcohol-fixed smears. CONCLUSION: The incidence of c-erbB-2 expression in fresh cytologic material is significantly higher (P < .05) than in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue. Alcohol-fixed smears demonstrate a slightly higher percentage of cell staining and stronger intensity of c-erbB-2 expression than the matched, air-dried smears. This is a sensitive and simple processing method that can be routinely applied in surgical pathology or fine needle aspiration biopsy specimens for the detection of c-erbB-2 (HER-2), with clinical implications.